CAC Payback Period

The CAC payback period is the number of months until the contribution margin a new customer brings in has repaid what it cost to acquire them. For D2C brands the first order decides most of it, and with it how much cash growth ties up.

Daniel Busch
Written by Daniel Busch · Chief of Staff · Updated

In short

  • Is: the months until the contribution margin of a new customer, after returns, adds up to their acquisition cost
  • Formula: the first month in which cumulative contribution margin per new customer reaches CAC. With a steady monthly margin, as in subscriptions: CAC ÷ monthly margin per customer
  • In D2C the first order brings most of the early margin. Paid back at the first order means every month of acquisition funds itself
  • Paid back at the first order when new-customer ROAS after returns is at least 1 ÷ contribution margin
  • What sets the month: the part of CAC the first order leaves open and how fast repeat orders close it. In the worked example, each euro left open takes about a month

What the CAC payback period measures

The payback period counts the months until a new customer has earned back their CAC in contribution margin:

CAC payback period = the first month in which cumulative contribution margin per new customer ≥ CAC

Three definitions make it work:

  • Contribution margin, not revenue. Use contribution margin 2 (CM2): revenue net of VAT, minus product costs, shipping, payment fees and returns. Revenue repays a CAC quickly but doesn’t pay for the products it bought.
  • Per new customer of a cohort. Average the margin over all customers acquired in the same month, including the many who never order again.
  • Month 0 is the first order. CAC is paid when the customer is won, so the first order’s margin counts at once.

Where every customer pays the same each month, as in subscriptions, the formula shortens to CAC ÷ monthly CM2 per customer. A D2C cohort repays in one large step and a long tail instead: the first order brings a big part of the margin, repeat orders from a minority of customers bring the rest, month by month.

Worked example: from first order to payback

A brand sells at €60 per order net of VAT and returns, keeps €24 of CM2 per order (40%) and pays a blended CAC of €50 per new customer. Its cohorts place, per new customer, 1.15 orders within 90 days, 1.5 within 12 months and 2.5 within 36 months:

Point in timeOrders per new customerCumulative CM2 per new customerStill to repay
First order1.00€24.00€26.00
90 days1.15€27.60€22.40
12 months1.50€36.00€14.00
Month 262.08€50.00€0.00

From month 13 on, the cohort adds one more order per customer over two years, €1.00 of CM2 per customer a month. The remaining €14 takes another 14 months: the payback period is 26 months. The same customers acquired for €30 instead of €50 pay back in month 6.

Why first-order profit decides D2C cash flow

Ad spend leaves your account in the month you win a customer; their margin comes back over years. In the example, each new customer leaves €26 unpaid after the first order. A brand that wins 1,000 new customers a month this way has about €240,000 of acquisition cost not yet earned back after one year, money that has to come from the bank, from investors or from the margin of older customers.

The other way round, a first order whose CM2 covers the CAC makes every month of acquisition pay for itself, and every repeat order is profit. That is why D2C brands with the same LTV:CAC can have very different cash positions: the LTV:CAC ratio says how much comes back by a horizon, the payback period says when.

The new-customer ROAS that pays back at the first order

A customer pays back at the first order when first-order CM2 ≥ CAC, so the first order pays back the CAC only when new-customer ROAS after returns reaches 1 ÷ CM2 margin. Below that, new-customer ROAS × CM2 margin is the share of CAC the first order repays, and repeat orders have to bring in the rest: the payback period is the month in which they have. In the worked example, €60 of first-order revenue for €50 of CAC is a new-customer ROAS of 1.2, so the first order repays 1.2 × 40% = 48% of the CAC and leaves 52%, the €26 above.

Which new-customer ROAS breaks even, on the first order and with repeat orders, is in the new-customer ROAS entry’s section on a good new-customer ROAS. Read it after returns: the break-even ROAS entry’s section on gross margin, with one customer’s returns shows how far new-customer ROAS fell in that customer’s data.

What is a good CAC payback period?

In SaaS, David Skok’s widely used guide says many of the best businesses recover their CAC in 5 to 7 months, and calls profitability anemic when it takes longer than 12 months (For Entrepreneurs). Those businesses repay in even monthly steps. A D2C cohort doesn’t, so two numbers say more than the month count: the share of CAC the first order repays, and the month the cohort crosses 100%.

Our view: for a D2C brand without subscriptions, aim for a payback at the first order on the prospecting you want to scale. Treat a payback beyond 12 months as a bet that your own cohorts have to back, not an LTV assumption. Subscription brands can plan on renewals, but only as far as their cohorts already renew.

In the worked example, the first order repays €24 of the €50 CAC, 48%, and repeat orders add about €1.00 of CM2 per customer a month. So every euro of CAC above those €24 adds about a month: the €26 left open takes until month 26. The LTV:CAC ratio entry shows how to use our panel’s medians below as reference inputs.

FAQ about CAC Payback Period

How do returns change the payback period?

They push it out, because the margin a new customer leaves only counts once the returns are in. A first order that seems to cover 80% of the CAC on the order date covers less once part of its revenue goes back, and repeat orders have to bring the rest. Read payback on revenue after returns, or on cohorts old enough for their returns to be in.

Should payback be calculated on revenue or on contribution margin?

On contribution margin, after product costs, shipping, payment fees and returns. CAC is cash you spent, and only the margin a customer leaves can pay it back. In the worked example, revenue repays the €50 CAC with the first order, contribution margin only in month 26.

How does a first-order discount change the payback period?

Further than the discount suggests. In the worked example, 20% off cuts the €60 first order to €48 while its €36 of costs stay, so it leaves €12 of CM2 instead of €24 and repays 24% of the €50 CAC instead of 48%. If those customers then order as often as the others, at full price, payback moves from month 26 to month 38. Whether they do, only their cohort shows, as the LTV entry’s answer on sale cohorts explains.

Should we measure the payback per channel?

Yes, with each channel’s own CAC and the cohort of new customers it brought: a blended payback can hide a channel that never pays back, as the LTV:CAC ratio entry’s worked example of two channels with one CAC shows.