Return Rate

Return rate is the share of sales that customers send back: orders with a return ÷ orders, returned items ÷ items sold, or refunded revenue ÷ revenue. The three give different numbers for the same shop, so a return rate needs its formula.

Daniel Busch
Written by Daniel Busch · Chief of Staff · Updated

In short

  • By orders: orders with a return ÷ orders. By items: returned items ÷ items sold. By value: refunded revenue ÷ revenue
  • Fashion returns most: in a 2026 EHI survey, 67.5% of fashion retailers had item return rates above 20%, while two thirds of all retailers stayed at or below 10%
  • Returns hit ROAS after the fact: a ROAS read in a campaign's first weeks still holds revenue that goes back
  • A return costs more than its refund: shipping both ways, handling, and a payment fee that doesn't come back
  • adtribute books a refund on the day of the order, Shopify on the day the refund is processed

How to calculate the return rate

Three formulas, three different numbers:

  • By orders: orders with at least one return ÷ orders
  • By items: returned items ÷ items sold
  • By value: refunded revenue ÷ revenue, both net of VAT

One month in a fashion shop: 1,200 orders with 3,000 items and €80,000 of net revenue before refunds. 360 orders send something back, 720 items return, €17,600 is refunded.

FormulaCalculationReturn rate
By orders360 ÷ 1,20030%
By items720 ÷ 3,00024%
By value€17,600 ÷ €80,00022%

Each answers a different question. The value rate is what leaves your net revenue, so it belongs in margin and ROAS. The item rate drives the work, because labels, handling and restocking are counted per item. The order rate says how many customers send something back. Benchmarks differ in the same way: the EHI survey below counts items, the University of Bamberg counted parcels.

Count returns against the orders they belong to, the orders of a month or of a campaign, not against the orders of the month the returns arrive in. Otherwise a strong sale month followed by a quiet one shows a return rate that jumps without anyone returning more.

Return rates by category

Fashion is where returns happen. In the EHI Retail Institute’s 2026 survey of 108 online retailers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, two thirds of all retailers reported an item return rate of 10% or less, and 23.6% one above 20%. In fashion, 67.5% reported more than 20%; in consumer electronics, none did (EHI, September 2026). Counted by parcels, the University of Bamberg estimated that almost every fourth parcel in German online retail went back in 2021, mostly in fashion (University of Bamberg, 2022).

The rules make returns easy. In the EU, consumers can withdraw from an online purchase within 14 days without giving a reason. The shop refunds the price, and if everything goes back also the standard delivery charge; the buyer pays the return shipping only if the shop said so before the purchase and didn’t offer to pay it (§ 357 BGB, implementing Directive 2011/83/EU). Most shops pay anyway: in the EHI survey, 60.6% of retailers covered return shipping in full in 2026, up from 49.2% a year earlier. In the Bamberg survey, German retailers offered free returns far more often than retailers in the rest of the EU: 88.7% against 52.4%.

What returns do to ROAS and contribution margin

Returns arrive after the reporting has moved on, so a ROAS read in a campaign’s first weeks still holds revenue that goes back. How far it fell in one customer’s data, and which break-even to compare it with before and after returns, is in the break-even ROAS entry’s section on returns.

The margin loss is larger than the refund, because the costs of the order stay. Per order, for a shop with free shipping and free returns:

Order keptOne of two items backBoth items back
Net revenue€100.00€50.00€0.00
− COGS, returned items back in stock€35.00€17.50€0.00
− Shipping and fulfilment€13.00€13.00€13.00
− Payment fee, not refunded€2.00€2.00€2.00
− Return label and handling€0.00€7.00€9.00
= CM2€50.00€10.50−€24.00

Sending back half the order’s value took 79% of its CM2, and a full return costs €24 on top of the lost sale. The payment fee stays with the provider on a refund, as the payment service provider entry explains. What handling costs varies widely: the University of Bamberg put transport and processing at €2.85 per returned item on average, and in EHI’s 2025 survey more than a quarter of retailers couldn’t put a number on their processing costs at all (EHI).

For targets, divide by the share customers keep: to land at a ROAS of 2.0 after returns of a sixth, a campaign has to show 2.4 in its first days. Better still, judge it on net revenue once the return window has passed, and on the expected return rate of its products until then. A campaign that sells your most-returned products should carry their return rate.

Refund date vs. order date

adtribute’s e-commerce attribution software counts a refund on the day of its order, Shopify’s reports on the day it is processed (Shopify). What that does to revenue in each tool is explained in gross vs. net revenue; for the return rate, it decides which month a return lands in. Say the fashion month above is September, and €5,000 of its €17,600 in refunds are processed in October. On the order date, all €17,600 stay with September, whose value return rate climbs to 22% as they arrive. On the processing date, September stops at €12,600, 16%, and October’s refunds carry €5,000 of September’s returns. Over both months the totals match; month by month they don’t.

Our view: read the return rate by order date when you judge campaigns and products, because a return belongs to the sale that caused it, and by processing date when you plan the warehouse, which handles returns the week they arrive. Why net revenue, too, belongs on the order date is in gross vs. net revenue.

FAQ about Return Rate

How do I calculate my return rate?

Divide what came back by what you sold, and say which unit you count: orders with a return by orders, returned items by items sold, or refunded revenue by revenue. For margin and ROAS, use the value rate; for logistics, the item rate. Count returns against the orders they belong to.

What is a normal return rate in fashion e-commerce?

High. In EHI’s 2026 survey of online retailers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, 67.5% of fashion retailers reported item return rates above 20%, against 23.6% of all retailers. In consumer electronics, none did.

How far will last month’s net revenue still fall?

By the refunds still to come, which its return rate by value lets you estimate. In the fashion month above, 22% by value takes €17,600 off €80,000 of net revenue before refunds: once its returns are in, the month ends at €62,400. In adtribute, which counts each refund on the day of its order, the month falls toward that figure as the refunds arrive.

Should ROAS targets be set before or after returns?

After returns, on net revenue, because that is what your break-even ROAS is calculated on. If you have to steer on revenue before returns, divide the target by the share customers keep: with a sixth of revenue returned, a target of 2.0 becomes 2.4.